Sainsbury's more expensive than Waitrose without Nectar, new comparison finds


You might expect a supermarket shop at Waitrose to cost more than one at Sainsbury's or Tesco, but new research suggests that isn't always the case, particularly if you're shopping without a loyalty card.
Consumer champion Which? has revealed that shoppers buying a selection of popular branded groceries could pay more at Sainsbury's and Tesco than at Waitrose if they don't use Nectar or Clubcard.
The comparison, published on 12 November 2026, tracked the prices of 211 branded products throughout October, including Heinz beans, Nescafé coffee and Mr Kipling cakes.
Asda came out cheapest overall, but the really interesting finding was just how much of a difference loyalty pricing made to the final bill.
Without Nectar, Sainsbury's was the most expensive supermarket in the comparison, while Tesco shoppers without a Clubcard also faced higher prices than those shopping at Waitrose.
And when we're all looking for ways to keep the food bill down ahead of Christmas, those differences are well worth paying attention to.
Is Sainsbury's really more expensive than Waitrose?
According to Which?'s October comparison, yes, Sainsbury's was more expensive than Waitrose for the particular selection of 211 branded products tested, if shoppers didn't use Nectar prices.
The average cost of the full shopping list was:
Sainsbury's without Nectar: £846.44
Tesco without Clubcard: £837.55
Waitrose: £814.40
Tesco with Clubcard: £765.53
Sainsbury's with Nectar: £758.14
Asda: £742.35
That means the Sainsbury's shopping list cost £32.04 more than Waitrose without Nectar, while Tesco was £23.15 more expensive without Clubcard.
But it's important to understand what those figures represent.
Which? tracked 211 branded groceries throughout October and calculated their average prices over the month. This isn't the cost of an average weekly food shop, and it doesn't mean every household would spend hundreds of pounds more by choosing one supermarket over another.
It does, however, demonstrate how dramatically loyalty pricing can change the relative cost of exactly the same branded products.
How much can you save with a Nectar card at Sainsbury's?
The most striking figure from the research was the difference between Sainsbury's standard prices and the prices available to Nectar customers.
Without Nectar, the 211 products cost an average of £846.44.
With Nectar, that fell to £758.14, a difference of £88.30 across the full comparison list.
That's a substantial gap, although it would be misleading to suggest that every Sainsbury's customer could save £88 on their weekly shop simply by signing up.
In fact, Which? found that 157 of the 211 products in its research were on loyalty promotion at Sainsbury's at some point during October.
That goes some way towards explaining the difference, because Nectar customers could access discounted prices on a large proportion of the products being tracked.
For anyone who regularly shops at Sainsbury's, it's worth checking whether you're using your Nectar card consistently, particularly when buying branded items.
But it's equally important not to confuse getting a lower price than a supermarket's standard shelf price with necessarily getting the cheapest price available anywhere.
How much cheaper is Tesco with Clubcard?
Tesco shoppers saw a similar difference, although it was slightly smaller than at Sainsbury's.
Without Clubcard, the full shopping list cost £837.55, compared with £765.53 for customers paying Clubcard prices.
That's a difference of £72.02 across the 211 products.
Which? recorded 134 products on Clubcard promotion during October, compared with 157 at Sainsbury's.
Interestingly, Tesco with Clubcard had been the cheapest supermarket for branded groceries in September, but Asda reclaimed the top spot in October.
That demonstrates why it's worth checking prices regularly rather than assuming the supermarket that was cheapest last month will necessarily offer the best value today.
If you're a Tesco shopper, it's also worth checking whether you have any unused Clubcard vouchers sitting in your account, as they can provide an additional saving beyond the prices displayed on the shelves.
Read our guide to the best ways to spend Tesco Clubcard vouchers to find out how to make the most of them.
Which supermarket is cheapest for branded groceries in 2026?
Asda was the cheapest supermarket in Which?'s October branded-groceries comparison, with the full shopping list costing £742.35.
Sainsbury's with Nectar was second at £758.14, followed by Tesco with Clubcard at £765.53.
Morrisons was next, at £771.11 with a More card or £775.45 without one, while Ocado and Waitrose were further down the comparison.
However, there's an important difference between being cheapest for branded groceries and being cheapest for an everyday food shop.
Aldi and Lidl weren't included in this particular comparison because they don't stock enough of the same branded products to make a like-for-like comparison possible.
In Which?'s separate October comparison of 87 everyday groceries, which included own-brand products, Aldi was cheapest at £154.34, followed by Lidl with Lidl Plus at £157.17.
So while Asda may offer good value for people who prefer particular brands, shoppers happy to swap to supermarket own-label products could find better value elsewhere.
Which branded groceries have the biggest price differences?
One of the most eye-opening examples from the research involved a pack of Tilda Boil in Bag Basmati Rice.
Which? found that the same 250g pack cost an average of just 95p at Asda but £2.15 at Sainsbury's without Nectar.
That's £1.20 more for exactly the same product, or a price difference of 126%.
Another example involved a pack of 50 Pampers Premium Protection nappies, which cost an average of £4 for Sainsbury's Nectar customers but £8.70 at the highest-priced retailers without loyalty discounts.
These aren't differences you'd necessarily notice if you always shop in the same place, particularly when you're rushing around trying to get the weekly groceries sorted.
But they illustrate why comparing the price of a few regular household staples can be more useful than simply assuming the supermarket advertising the biggest discount is offering the best deal.
Are supermarket loyalty prices always cheaper?
Not necessarily, and this is where shoppers need to look beyond the brightly coloured shelf labels.
Loyalty prices can offer genuine savings, particularly if you're buying products you already intended to purchase.
However, a product being advertised at a discounted member price doesn't automatically mean it's cheaper than the equivalent product at another supermarket.
For example, a £4 product reduced to £3 for loyalty members might look like a decent saving, but if another supermarket sells it for £2.50, you're still spending 50p more than necessary.
It's also worth thinking about how loyalty offers influence what ends up in your basket.
A discount on something you regularly buy can be useful, but picking up an extra product simply because it's on a member-only promotion doesn't necessarily leave you better off.
And if you're switching from a cheaper own-brand alternative to a discounted branded product, you might find you're spending more despite apparently getting a bargain.
The best way to judge an offer is to compare the actual amount you're paying, rather than the size of the advertised discount.
Are Nectar, Clubcard and other supermarket loyalty cards worth it?
If you regularly shop at Tesco or Sainsbury's, having access to Clubcard or Nectar prices can make a noticeable difference to the cost of eligible purchases.
Both schemes are free to join, meaning you don't have to pay a membership fee to access the discounts.
However, it's worth remembering that retailers collect information about customers' shopping habits through loyalty schemes, and not everyone is comfortable exchanging that information for discounts.
Supermarkets also offer different types of loyalty benefits. Some reduce prices immediately at checkout, while others give customers points, vouchers or cashback to use towards future purchases.
Those rewards can be valuable, but they're not always equivalent to an immediate reduction in the cost of groceries, particularly if they come with expiry dates or minimum redemption requirements.
The important thing is to make sure you're getting value from the scheme rather than allowing its offers to dictate what you buy.
Five ways to make your supermarket discounts work harder
If you're already scanning your loyalty card at every shop, you might assume you're getting everything you're entitled to. But there's often more to supermarket savings than the prices advertised on the shelves, and some of the most useful discounts need a little attention before you reach the checkout.
1. Unlock your personalised Nectar Prices before shopping
Here's something Sainsbury's shoppers might be missing: ordinary Nectar Prices and Your Nectar Prices aren't the same thing.
While standard Nectar Prices are available to all eligible members, Your Nectar Prices are personalised offers based on your shopping habits. You can receive up to ten each week, with new offers appearing every Friday.
To use them, open the Nectar app, head to the Sainsbury's section and look for Your Nectar Prices. You can then unlock the discounts you want before shopping, and they'll be applied to eligible purchases when you scan your Nectar card.
These personalised discounts don't necessarily appear on shelf labels, so you could be walking past a better price without realising it's available to you.
It's well worth spending a minute checking before your regular shop, particularly if you've already decided which products you're buying.
2. Add Tesco coupons directly to your Clubcard
Tesco has made another useful change that could help shoppers avoid missing discounts.
If you've received personalised money-off coupons or extra-points offers, you can now add eligible coupons directly to your Clubcard through the Tesco app.
Open the Clubcard section, find your available coupons and select 'Add to Clubcard'. The coupons you've added should then be applied automatically when you scan your Clubcard in store, provided you've met their conditions.
That means you don't have to remember to produce several different vouchers at the checkout, which is particularly handy when you're trying to pack your shopping before the next person's groceries start coming down the conveyor belt.
It's also worth checking the vouchers section for Clubcard points you've already converted into money-off vouchers, particularly with £15 million worth due to expire at the end of November.
3. Check Morrisons More offers and Asda Rewards missions
Tesco and Sainsbury's aren't the only supermarkets offering savings beyond their standard loyalty prices.
Morrisons More customers can receive personalised offers and money-off coupons through the More app, alongside More Card Prices and points that can be converted into £5 vouchers once they've collected enough.
Asda Rewards works differently, with shoppers able to complete qualifying missions to build up money in their Cashpot, which can then be converted into vouchers.
The trick with these schemes is to check what you're being offered before deciding whether it's worth changing your shop.
If Asda is offering a reward for something you already intended to buy, that's a useful extra. If completing the mission means putting another £20 worth of products in your basket, the reward may not be quite as generous as it first appears.
Likewise, a personalised Morrisons offer on a regular purchase could be worth using, but there's little value in buying something simply because the app has decided you'd probably like it.
4. Stack eligible discounts and cashback where possible
One of the better ways to save more without changing what you buy is to look at how you're paying for it.
Some banking and rewards programmes offer cashback on eligible supermarket spending, while others let customers buy discounted supermarket gift cards.
For example, eligible thinkmoney Smart Plus customers can access discounted supermarket gift vouchers through PlusSave, with offers available for retailers including Tesco, Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Asda, Iceland and Farmfoods. Offers and discounts can change, so check what's currently available before buying.
Where the supermarket's rules allow it, paying with a discounted gift card while also using loyalty prices can mean getting money off the same planned shop in two different ways.
It's also worth checking whether your bank has any card-linked cashback offers available before paying, although these won't necessarily apply to gift-card purchases and individual schemes have their own exclusions.
The important part is that you're getting an additional saving on money you were already planning to spend, rather than committing to a bigger shop just to earn a reward.
5. Look beyond the obvious aisle, especially for ingredients you buy regularly
Some of the best supermarket savings have nothing to do with loyalty cards.
Take the world foods aisle, where products such as rice, lentils, chickpeas and spices can sometimes cost considerably less than similar ingredients in the main grocery aisles.
It's especially worth checking when you're buying things like paprika, cumin or dried pulses, where a small branded jar can cost much more per gram than a larger packet from another part of the same supermarket.
And if you're choosing ingredients for meals you cook regularly, don't overlook the frozen section. Frozen vegetables, fruit and other staples can be cheaper than fresh alternatives, while giving you the flexibility to use only what you need rather than watching the rest deteriorate in the fridge.
The reduced section can be another useful stop, particularly for bread, meat and other products that can be frozen before their use-by dates.
The aim isn't to spend your Saturday touring every aisle looking for a few pence, but to find a handful of swaps that work for the meals you already make, and keep benefiting from them each week.
For more ideas, we've covered why the cheapest supermarket products aren't always the best value, including the impact of quality, waste and products that don't last as long as you'd expect.
Supermarket loyalty prices: Frequently asked questions
Is Sainsbury's more expensive than Waitrose?
For the 211 branded products compared by Which? in October 2026, Sainsbury's without Nectar was more expensive than Waitrose by £32.04. However, this doesn't mean Sainsbury's is more expensive for every shopping basket.
How much does Nectar save at Sainsbury's?
In Which?'s October comparison, the 211-product shopping list cost £88.30 less with Nectar prices than without them. Your actual savings will depend on which products you buy and which offers are available.
Is Tesco cheaper with a Clubcard?
Clubcard customers can access lower prices on selected products. In Which?'s October comparison, the shopping list cost £72.02 less with Clubcard prices than without them.
Which supermarket is cheapest without a loyalty card?
Asda was cheapest in Which?'s October comparison of 211 branded products. However, Aldi was cheapest in its separate comparison of 87 everyday groceries, including own-brand items.
Is Nectar better than Clubcard?
It depends on which supermarket you use and which products you buy. Nectar customers received the cheaper branded shopping list in October, but Tesco Clubcard prices had come out ahead in September.
Do supermarket loyalty cards actually save money?
They can, particularly when discounts apply to products you already buy. However, the best way to judge value is to compare the actual price with other supermarkets rather than relying solely on the advertised loyalty saving.
The cheapest supermarket isn't always the one offering the biggest discount
The latest comparison is a useful reminder that supermarket pricing is becoming increasingly complicated, particularly when different customers can pay very different amounts for the same products depending on whether they've scanned a loyalty card.
There's nothing wrong with taking advantage of a good Nectar or Clubcard deal, and the savings on regular purchases can be substantial.
But if the price of a product changes dramatically depending on whether you're signed up to a scheme, it's worth asking how competitive that price really is in the first place.
Ultimately, saving money on groceries isn't about collecting the most loyalty points or finding the biggest yellow discount label. It's about getting the things you actually need at a price that works for your budget, without spending more than you intended along the way.

< Back to articles
