thinkmoney logo

Universal Credit accounts three times more likely to have Direct Debits fail, new figures reveal

Vix Leyton
Written by Vix Leyton
Consumer Finance Expert and Head of Communications & Content at thinkmoney
19th Nov 2026
2 minute read

New government figures have revealed that Direct Debits from bank accounts receiving Universal Credit are failing at more than three times the national average, raising concerns about how people on benefits are managing essential household bills.

According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), 7.44% of Direct Debit transactions linked to accounts receiving Universal Credit failed in October 2026, compared with 2.38% across all consumers.

Published on Thursday 19 November, the figures highlight a problem that can quickly become expensive. A failed Direct Debit could leave someone facing additional charges, missed bill payments and potentially damage to their credit score.

But what happens if your Direct Debit fails, and can you change your Universal Credit payment dates to make bills easier to manage?

What happens if a Direct Debit fails?

A Direct Debit usually fails when there isn't enough money in your bank account to cover the payment.

Your bank may reject the transaction, leaving the company collecting the payment without the money it was expecting.

Depending on your bank, you might receive a notification giving you time to transfer money into your account before the payment is rejected. Some banks may try the payment again later that day.

If the payment fails, the company could contact you to arrange another payment or attempt to collect the money again.

A failed Direct Debit doesn't mean the bill disappears. You'll still owe the outstanding amount, and depending on the type of bill, there could be additional consequences.

Will a failed Direct Debit affect your credit score?

A failed Direct Debit doesn't automatically damage your credit score, but the missed payment behind it might.

If your Direct Debit was paying a loan, credit card or another credit agreement, failing to make the payment could result in a missed payment being recorded on your credit file.

Missed payments can remain on your credit report for six years, potentially making it harder to borrow money in the future.

However, not every Direct Debit is connected to a credit agreement, and a rejected payment doesn't automatically mean a missed payment will be reported.

The important thing is to contact the company and arrange to pay what you owe as quickly as possible.

Do banks charge for failed Direct Debits?

Some banks charge fees for unpaid Direct Debits, although many have stopped doing so.

You might also face charges from the company collecting the payment, depending on the type of agreement you have.

If you've been charged, check your bank account terms and ask whether the fee can be refunded, particularly if you're experiencing financial difficulties.

Before paying the bill manually, check whether the company has already arranged another collection. You don't want to pay twice.

Which benefit recipients have the highest Direct Debit failure rates?

The latest ONS figures reveal a considerable difference between the failure rates of Direct Debits linked to different benefit payments.

In October 2026, the proportion of failed Direct Debits was:

  • Universal Credit: 7.44%

  • Maternity Allowance: 5.76%

  • Carer's Allowance: 5.36%

  • All consumers: 2.38%

  • Attendance Allowance: 0.34%

  • State Pension: 0.29%

This means the failure rate for accounts receiving Universal Credit was more than three times the overall rate.

The data are based on anonymised payment transactions, rather than the number of individual people missing payments. Accounts can also be associated with more than one benefit.

The difference between the benefit groups is striking, particularly given that Direct Debits are intended to make managing bills simpler.

Why are Direct Debits failing more often for people receiving Universal Credit?

Universal Credit is usually paid monthly, meaning recipients need to make a single payment stretch across an entire month of household expenses.

For anyone living on a tight budget, that can create problems when payments don't line up neatly.

Rent, energy, broadband, council tax, mobile phones and insurance might all come out on different dates.

And while the amount of money someone receives might technically be enough to cover their essential bills, it doesn't necessarily mean the money will be in their account when a Direct Debit is collected.

For people who work while receiving Universal Credit, changes in earnings can also affect their benefit payments from one month to the next.

Deductions for advance repayments or certain debts can further reduce the amount arriving in their bank account.

The ONS figures don't establish exactly why individual payments have failed, but they expose a significant difference in how successfully different groups are meeting scheduled payments.

A Direct Debit is supposed to make paying bills easier, but it can only work when there's enough money available on the day the payment is taken.

How to stop Direct Debits failing: five practical steps

If you've had a Direct Debit rejected, or you're worried about an upcoming payment, there are ways to make bills easier to manage.

1. Change your Direct Debit collection dates

One of the most useful changes is to arrange for essential bills to come out shortly after your income arrives.

For example, if your Universal Credit is paid on the 15th of every month, you could ask your energy supplier, broadband provider and other companies whether they can collect payments on the 16th or 17th.

Many providers offer some flexibility around collection dates.

This won't reduce what you owe, but it could help prevent money being spent elsewhere before important bills are paid.

Check whether changing the date will affect your next bill, as some companies may adjust the amount or timing of the first payment.

2. Keep your bill money separate

When all your money sits in one account, it can be difficult to tell how much is genuinely available to spend.

Consider using a separate account or budgeting feature to keep the money needed for essential bills away from your everyday spending.

For example, if you receive £1,200 and know £750 needs to cover essential Direct Debits and other fixed payments, setting that money aside immediately leaves a clearer picture of what you have available for everything else.

You can also use reminders to check your balance before important bills are due.

3. Check your Universal Credit deductions

The amount of Universal Credit you're awarded isn't necessarily the amount that reaches your bank account.

You could have money deducted to repay an advance or certain outstanding debts.

Check your monthly Universal Credit statement to see exactly what's being deducted.

If deductions are leaving you unable to afford essentials, contact the DWP through your Universal Credit journal to discuss whether an eligible repayment can be reduced.

4. Contact companies before a payment fails

If you know you won't have enough money to cover an upcoming Direct Debit, contact the company before collection day.

Depending on the provider, you might be able to change your payment date, agree to pay in instalments or arrange a temporary payment plan.

Energy suppliers must take account of customers' ability to pay when arranging repayments.

It's worth having the conversation before a payment fails rather than waiting until additional charges or arrears build up.

5. Check whether you're missing out on financial support

If your income isn't covering essential bills, adjusting Direct Debit dates may only be part of the solution.

Check whether you're receiving all the benefits and financial assistance you're entitled to.

Depending on your circumstances, you might qualify for Council Tax Reduction, help with energy costs or other local support.

If you're already falling behind, free debt advice from Money Wellness can help you prioritise payments and understand your options.

Can you change your Universal Credit payment date?

Universal Credit is normally paid on the same date each month, and you generally can't choose a different payday to match your bills.

If your usual payment date falls on a weekend or bank holiday, you'll normally receive the money on the working day before.

However, if you're struggling to manage one monthly payment, you may be able to request an Alternative Payment Arrangement.

This could change how frequently you receive your Universal Credit or allow the housing element to be paid directly to your landlord.

You can ask about this through your Universal Credit journal or by speaking to your work coach.

Can you get Universal Credit paid twice a month?

Yes. Some Universal Credit claimants can receive payments twice a month rather than once.

In England and Wales, people who are struggling to manage monthly payments can request an Alternative Payment Arrangement from the DWP.

These arrangements are assessed individually and aren't automatically available simply because someone would prefer to receive their money more frequently.

In Scotland, Universal Credit claimants can choose whether to receive payments once or twice a month under the Scottish Choices system.

Northern Ireland normally pays Universal Credit twice monthly, although claimants can request monthly payments.

Receiving Universal Credit more frequently doesn't increase the total amount you're entitled to, but it may make budgeting easier if you struggle to make one payment last the entire month.

What should you do if you can't afford your next Direct Debit?

If you're worried that a Direct Debit is about to fail, start by looking at which payments have the most serious consequences if missed.

Rent, mortgage payments, council tax and energy bills should generally take priority over less essential commitments.

Contact the companies involved and explain what you can realistically afford.

If you're considering cancelling a Direct Debit, remember that cancelling the instruction through your bank won't cancel the bill or any agreement behind it.

You may still owe the money and could face charges or other consequences for not paying.

If you're struggling with several bills at once, getting free debt advice can help you understand which payments need urgent attention.

The new ONS figures show that payment problems are disproportionately affecting accounts receiving Universal Credit.

For people whose income is already stretched, even one failed Direct Debit can create additional financial pressure. Making bill collection dates work around income, checking benefit deductions and asking for help early can reduce the risk of a manageable shortfall becoming a much more serious problem.

Vix Leyton
Written by Vix Leyton

< Back to articles